Wassergekühlter Elektromotor – Problemlöser für Konstruktionsgrenzen

Water-Cooled Electric Motors – Problem-Solver for Design Constraints

Air-cooled motors are all-rounders: robust, durable and also economical in S1 duty. However, they reach their limits when quiet operation and limited installation space must be combined with high power in continuous operation. Our Head of Design, Stefan Kunzmann, explains how water-cooled motors can act as problem-solvers in these cases.

Air-cooled electric motors are robust all-rounders suitable for a wide range of industrial applications. When do they reach their limits?

Above all, an air-cooled motor needs space. When more power is needed, the motor becomes larger and heavier and requires additional space to draw in air. If space is limited but high power is still required, an alternative is needed. Air cooling is also ineffective when the ambient temperature is already high, as it merely circulates warm air over the motor. Similarly, air-cooled motors are unsuitable for use in cleanrooms and laboratories where particles must not be stirred up or the ambient temperature must not be raised by the motor’s waste heat.

So these limitations speak in favour of water-cooled electric motors?

Exactly. In these cases, water-cooled motors are the ideal choice: they are more compact and lighter while delivering the same or higher power output, because cooling water dissipates heat more efficiently than air. As a result, hardly any waste heat is released into the room; since there is no fan, the motor runs quietly and does not stir up any particles.

Given these advantages, is a water-cooled motor generally an alternative to an air-cooled motor?

No. As long as air cooling is sufficient for operation (whether fan-cooled or simply surface-cooled), it is simpler and more economical to stick with it. Because of their more complex internal design, water-cooled motors are more expensive to buy. They also need a cooling unit and pipework, which can mean additional cost and effort. However, as soon as certain design constraints rule out an air-cooled motor, the water-cooled motor is the problem-solver.

So what are the limitations of water-cooled motors?

The main challenges with water-cooled motors are the higher capital and additional costs. In particular, the necessary peripheral equipment – comprising the cooling unit, pump, pipework and sensors – must be taken into account. If this cooling circuit has to be set up from scratch, the purchase of a water-cooled motor should be carefully assessed. The situation is different if a cooling system already exists into which the water-cooled motor can be integrated. In that case, most of the additional costs are eliminated.

The maintenance requirements for a water-cooled motor are also slightly higher than for an air-cooled one, since several parameters must be monitored continuously: the flow temperature of the coolant (usually a maximum of 38 °C), the pressure and the flow rate. If the motor is connected in series within the cooling circuit, care must be taken to ensure that the flow temperature is not too high. Otherwise, an additional unit for intermediate cooling would be needed. The pressure and flow rate must be sufficient to prevent air from accumulating in the system.

How does water cooling affect the motor’s efficiency?

When the motor is considered in isolation, its cooling capacity enables it to achieve high efficiency classes (IE4 or IE5) without increasing the size of the housing. With an air-cooled motor, considerably more material would be needed for the same power output; the frame size would be larger, the motor heavier, and electrical and thermal losses would increase.

However, you have to consider the overall system into which the water-cooled drive is integrated. The external cooling circuit also consumes electricity, which means that the motor’s efficiency advantage is partially offset, particularly if the cooling system has to be built specifically for the motor.

In which sectors and applications are water-cooled motors particularly suitable?

There are scenarios in which a water-cooled motor is the drive of choice. If the necessary infrastructure – that is, a cooling circuit – is already in place, for example on ships, in switchgear or in large frequency converters, there is hardly any additional effort involved; the motor is integrated into the system and also benefits from the higher efficiency.

Incidentally, it is also possible to use an existing hydraulic circuit for liquid cooling; however, the oil in this circuit dissipates heat slightly less effectively than water.

A further note on the coolant: salt water is not suitable. A customer in the shipbuilding industry understandably wanted to use salt water for cooling, but we strongly advise against this. The aggressive salt water corrodes the steel cooling channels too heavily, causing them to wear out more quickly.

The second scenario concerns the installation space: where compactness and low weight are essential – such as on smaller ships or in compact industrial plants and production machinery – the cost of the pipework pays for itself from the outset. In the food and pharmaceutical industries, where fan impellers are to be avoided at all costs as they stir up dust and particles, the smooth, enclosed surface of the water-cooled motor – which we can supply up to IP69K depending on customer requirements – is ideal.

Last but not least, the water-cooled motor excels in ‘quiet’ applications, such as test benches or enclosed production halls, where staff would be disturbed by noisier fan-cooled motors. A fan is the main source of noise in a motor, while water cooling significantly reduces noise levels.

 

Learn more about our water-cooled electric motors here.